[Music] Trouble At the Henhouse – The Tragically Hip (1996)

Collaboration post! Sarca from Caught Me Gaming and Kevin from Buried On Mars take on The Tragically Hip, Canada’s National band! Each week, we will travel through the history of releases by The Tragically Hip, going through EVERYTHING they’ve ever released in audio and video form – studio album, live show, video releases. So don’t forget to check out Kevin’s blog too!

Need to catch up? Previously:

I never actually owned a copy of the Tragically Hip’s fifth studio album, Trouble at the Henhouse, until a few years ago. What can I say; as much as I heard it over the summer of 1996 thanks in part to a friend who purchased the album, I never felt the pull to buy my own copy. Back then, the album seemed unbalanced in its offerings. Even now, listening to the album with refreshed ears with several revolutions on the platter this week, I can say that other than a few standout songs, Henhouse still doesn’t speak to me like the Hip’s previous efforts.

While Day For Night was a grittier, moodier album, Henhouse has seemingly stripped the grime away to get back to acoustic fundamentals. Of note is that Gord Downie’s voice, for the most part, takes centre stage instead of getting drowned out by the rest of the band. We benefit immediately in the first song, Gift Shop, with Gord’s vocals, crisp and clean. The track begins quietly, only to crescendo into a full rock song; a method that has become a Hip staple – seen again in the following song, Springtime in Vienna. Ahead By a Century is next, and is Henhouse‘s magnum opus; it’s pretty much a perfect song musically and lyrically. How can your heart not sing “tonight we smoke them ouuut“? It is certainly no surprise that it was a massive hit for the Hip.

I would be remiss not to mention other decent tunes on Henhouse: the bar room rocker 700 Ft Ceiling, the droning guitar strumming in the chorus of Don’t Wake Daddy (the air guitar comes out for this bad boy), and the dreamy sustained guitar in Sherpa that reminds me a lot of the Black Crowes.

The rest of the album’s songs miss the mark with me; I perceive them to be a string of forgettable unrefined tunes (Butts Wigglin, Let’s Stay Engaged), some with overprocessed vocals (Coconut Cream: Gord sounds tinny) or even icky lyrics (Apartment Song: she hates her ugly feet, and I hate this song). Now, before I start hearing the cats mee-ow from the audience, I am critiquing this with peace and love…and concern since it seems the Hip boys lost steam after writing such greats in Gift Shop and Ahead By a Century. It is almost as though the rest of the album needed to be left in the oven a little while longer to let them rise.

Overall, Trouble at the Henhouse does fare better than the Hip’s EP; it’s certainly better produced. But, one thing is for sure, after many spins, I am still having difficulty reaching the songs… or having the songs reach me on a higher level. Maybe I need to spin it some more?

3/5 for me.

Trouble at the Henhouse
Tragically Hip

Thanks for reading! Make sure to check out Kevin’s take!


  1. Kinda funny how Kev can figure out the same scoring as you on a HIP album but he can’t figure out how long it will take Bond to get laid in his Bond series as your schooling him on that!

    Liked by 2 people

  2. “Apartment Song: she hates her ugly feet, and I hate this song,” I really like that part. Very straight to the point and not holding anything back haha. I like the animal references too. Great review Sarah!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I believe my wife actually had a copy of this on CD at one point. But I’m realizing something as I read yours and Kevin’s posts. I don’t think I’ve ever actually sat down and listened to one of Tragically Hip’s studio albums in full. Of course, I’ve heard them on the radio forever, saw them live once, and I’ve got a copy of “Yer favourites” but their albums? Nope. Perhaps I should take the time at some point.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. None of this was even vaguely familiar when I listened earlier, so I reckon I must never have listened to this one. As I was saying at Kev’s, I gave it a listen prior to reading your reviews… and I didn’t enjoy – it feels a bit thin and like an outtakes compilation (definitely some half baked tunes on here).

    Liked by 1 person

  5. I like this one more than you and Mars. After missing out on the previous album I guess I was ready for some new material I got it as a gift so someone was sending me a message. I want that dog off the cover. I love the groove on ‘Put It Off’

    Liked by 1 person

  6. The Gift Shop – Springtime in Vienna – Ahead By a Century trifecta might be their strongest album opening trio.
    But I don’t disagree, the second side isn’t all that memorable. I like the atmosphere in Put it Off & even years later, Butts Wigglin benefits from the Kids in the Hall: Brain Candy connection, but the tracks in between…
    That being said, on side 1, Flamenco is another fabulous tune. For whatever reason, I was thinking that would be the one they’d do with Feist.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s